Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Penn State Wrestling

Penn State Wrestling: Projecting The 2025-26 Starting Lineup

Penn State wrestling coach Cael Sanderson and football coach James Franklin have developed a bond over the past decade, and that bond has led to Sanderson speaking to the football team.
Photo by Penn State Athletics: Cael Sanderson

Itโ€™s a little early to talk about next yearโ€™s Penn State wrestling lineup.

But I donโ€™t care.

Penn State just landed a world champ in Japanโ€™s Masanosuke Ono, so heโ€™ll obviously be part of the projection.

Itโ€™s Official: World Champ Masanosuke Ono Will Compete for Penn State Wrestling

But where will he fit? Who will replace five-time champ Carter Starocci at 184, or five-time All-American and 2024 national Greg Kerkvliet at heavyweight? Will any true freshman become Day 1 starters the way Luke Lilledahl did at 125 this year (he ended up finishing third at NCAAs).

In any case, Penn State is almost certainly going to win its 13th national title in 15 seasons next year. But who will be the 10 that compete in Cleveland?

Letโ€™s get into it.

125

Luke Lilledahlย 

Thereโ€™s no reason to think All-American Luke Lilledahl will be back at 125 for Penn State next season.

Photo by Penn State wrestling: Luke Lilledahl

Itโ€™s hard to keep weight at 125 but itโ€™s also hard to imagine Lilledahl going anywhere else. He came into this yearโ€™s NCAA Championships as the No. 1 seed and finished third, so one would think heโ€™d be one of, if not the favorite at the weight class next season. Braeden Davis did move from 125 to 133 after last season but a big part of that was the fact that Lilledahl, the top-ranked recruit at 125, was coming in. There isnโ€™t somebody on that level coming in at that weight class for Penn State this season, so Lilledahl will be back.

133

Braeden Davis

Will Penn State wrestling starter Braeden Davis make it to the podium at nationals this year?

Photo by Penn State Athletics: Braeden Davis

If Ono isnโ€™t at 133โ€“ which is his current weight classโ€” Davis, who just took fifth at the national championshipsโ€” should be the guy. He had an up-and-down sophomore season, dealing with injuries throughout the year but ended up becoming an All-American for the first time. We canโ€™t forget about Aaron Nagao, who missed all of this season with an injury and was a national semifinalist just two seasons ago, or true freshman Marcus Blaze, who is in that weight range. But itโ€™s hard to see anybody unseating Davis at 133, unless itโ€™s the world champ himself.

141

Masanosuke Ono

The question isnโ€™t if Ono will start, itโ€™s where he will. There really isnโ€™t a wrong answer. His competitive weight is closer to 133, so 133 and 141 are the only realistic options. But because Penn State doesnโ€™t have a locked on 141-pounder right now, that seems to be the best option. But it can change.

149

Shayne Van Ness

Van Ness, like Lilledahl at 125, is right on the brink of a national title at 149, having finished third at NCAAs. Thereโ€™s no reason to think his status will change.

157

Tyler Kasak

Photo by Penn State Wrestling: Tyler Kasak

See Van Ness and Lilledahl. Kasak also finished third and is on the brink of a national title.

165

Mitchell Mesenbrink

For Penn State wrestling star Mitchell Mesenbrink, winning the Hodge Trophy would be โ€œsweet,โ€ but no on be-all, end-all

Photo by Penn State Wrestling: Mitchell Mesenbrink

The defending champ is the best in the world at his class. Why would that change?

174

Levi Haines

Penn State wrestling star Levi Haines is still in good spirits following a rare loss.

Photo by Penn State Athletics: Levi Haines

Many thought Hainesโ€” who won it all at 157 in 2024โ€“ would do the same at 174 this year. It wasnโ€™t to be, and he finished third. So like with several of his teammates, Haines has unfinished business at his weight class.

184

Zack Ryder

Nobody is going to be Carter Starocci at 184. Thereโ€™s only one Starocci and only one five-time champ. But Penn State should be just fine with Ryder. He was a four-time champ in high school, an U20 World Silver medalist and the No. 5 overall recruit in the Class of 2024. Yeah, Penn State will be ok.

197

Josh Barr

Penn State wrestling star Josh Barr was one win away from winning it all in 2025.

Photo by Penn State Wrestling: Josh Barr

He came one win away from taking it all this year. Barr, who started his career at 184, more than held his own at 197. Heโ€™s not moving to heavyweight, so heโ€™s right where he needs to be.

Heavyweight

Cole Mirasola

This might be the biggest question mark Penn State has. Replacing a five-time All-American and 2024 national champ in Greg Kerkvliet wonโ€™t be easy. Mirasola only has two matches under his beltโ€” losing bothโ€” so there isnโ€™t much of a sample to go on.

Letโ€™s see if heโ€™s up to the task.

Get NSN in your Inbox

Enter your email address to get notifications of new posts by email.

More from Nittany Sports Now

Penn State Wrestling

7s A former Penn State wrestling star has undergone surgery. Last month at the National Championships in Philaphia, all 10 Penn State starters earned...

Penn State Wrestling

5s Today marks the anniversary of the most important day in Penn State wrestling history. In March 2009, Penn State finished 17th at the...

Penn State Wrestling

0 A trio of Penn State wrestling competitors to home gold medals this weekend. Competing at the U23 Pan American Championships, a pair of...

Penn State Wrestling

3s Iowa wrestling starter Gabe Arnold opened up in a lengthy Instagram post. Arnold, who wrestled his first full season in Iowa City after...