Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Penn State Wrestling

Who Else?: Penn State Wrestling Star Carter Starocci Named Most Outstanding Wrestler

It’s been a bad week for Penn State wrestling.
Photo by Penn State Athletics: Carter Starocci

Philadelphia— Penn State wrestling star Carter Starocci has another notch on his belt— most outstanding wrestler at this year’s NCAA Championships.

Starocci, who became the first in history to win five national titles, was voted by the NCAA as the best, something he’s used to being.

It all started in front of a crowd that was only 25% field.

With things just starting to get back to semi-normal from COVID-19 in March 2021, Starocci, then a redshirt freshman, averaged his Big Ten Tournament loss to Iowa’s Michael Kemerer with his first national title win.

The next season, Starocci— competing with a broken hand— beat Virginia Tech’s Mekhi Lewis for his second title.

The only semi-normal title win for Starocci came in 2023 when he pinned Nebraska’s Mikey Labriola to three peat. In 2024, Starocci had the title win that people might remember most.

Add Nittany Sports Now as a preferred source in Google! Click here to add us.

Competing on a badly injured knee, Starocci beat two former national champs— Lewis in the quarters and Michigan’s Shane Griffith in the semis— before becoming the seventh wrestler to win four national titles by beating Ohio State’s Rocco Welsh in the finals.

Then, of course, he became the first to win five, beating Iowa’s Parker Keckeisen 4-3 and shaking hands with President Trump soon after.

For Starocci, being named Most Outstanding Wrestler was neat but what mattered most was Penn State’s team title.

Penn State, with a tournament record 177 points,  took home its 12 national title in 14 season.

“I mean, it’s cool,” Starocci told Nittany Sports Now exclusively afterward, “but for me, it’s just our team winning. For me, that’s the thing you earn. That’s important for me.”

Get NSN in your Inbox

Enter your email address to get notifications of new posts by email.

More from Nittany Sports Now

Penn State Football Recruiting

0s One of Penn State football’s top recruiting targets plans on playing in the Big Ten, but not for Penn State. Khalil Taylor, a...

Penn State Football Recruiting

3s Penn State has lost one of its Class of 2027 commitments to Rutgers. Hayes Fawcett of Rivals and On3Sports reported early Monday afternoon...

Penn State Football All 105

0s This is one in a series of stories breaking down each of the players on Penn State Football’s 2026 roster. A four-star recruit...

All 105

0s This is one in a series of stories breaking down each player on Penn State football’s 2026 roster. James Peoples already knows what...