Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

PSU Basketball

Who is greatest PSU basketball player of all time? Panel of experts weighs in

Photo by Penn State Athletics: Talor Battle

With Lamar Stevens getting set for the NBA draft tonight, it’s fun to revisit this question: Who is the greatest Penn State basketball player of all time?

The answer is, in fact, Stevens, according to a survey conducted earlier this year with local media members who follow PSU basketball closest.

I conducted the poll in March when I was still working for the Altoona Mirror. The voters were: Me, Nate Bauer of BlueWhite Illustrated, Mark Brennan of Lions247 with Fight On State, Ben Jones of StateCollege.com, David Jones of PennLive.com and Neil Rudel of the Altoona Mirror.

We all voted for first, second and third place. First place received 3 points, second place 2 points and third place 1 point.

Perhaps it was recency bias, since the poll was conducted at the conclusion of Stevens’ stellar career, or maybe all of Stevens’ accomplishments truly do warrant the top spot.

Either way, Stevens finished first by a slim margin over Battle, with Crispin coming in third and 1950s legend Jesse Arnelle in fourth. Arnelle just passed away a month ago at age 86.

Here are the voting results:

  1. Lamar Stevens (11)

  2. Talor Battle (10)

  3. Joe Crispin (8)

  4. Jesse Arnelle (3)

  5. Titus Ivory (2)

  6. Jarrett Stephens (1)

  7. D.J. Newbill (1)

Here is how each member of the panel voted:

Nate Bauer: 1. Battle, 2. Stevens, 3. Newbill

Mark Brennan: 1. Stevens, 2. Crispin, 3. Battle

Ben Jones: 1. Arnelle, 2. Battle, 3. Stevens

David Jones: 1. Crispin, 2. Battle, 3. Ivory

Neil Rudel: 1. Stevens, 2. Crispin, 3. Battle

Cory Giger: 1. Battle, 2. Stevens, 3. Crispin

For the record, I went with Battle because he not only was a great scorer, he was incredibly clutch late in games. He made so many big shots during his career, from off-balance jumpers to deep 3s, that either won or tied games, and that’s when everyone in the gym knew he was going to be shooting the ball.

Stevens was a better all-around player at PSU than Battle, but there were a number of games where Stevens would miss a big free throw or jumper late in close losses. That led to my decision to put him behind Battle but ahead of Crispin, who had long been No. 2 on my list because of his brilliant shooting career and leading PSU to the Sweet 16 in 2001.

Get Nittany Sports Now in your inbox

Sign-up for email updates and get the whole story first from Cory Giger and the Nittany Sports Now team, delivered straight to your inbox.

Thank you for subscribing.

Something went wrong.

Written By

Cory Giger is a 15-year veteran of the Penn State beat and a journalist with 28 years of experience. He has won more than 100 state and national journalism awards during his career, plus he's a voter for the Heisman Trophy in football and Wooden Award in basketball.

Click to comment

Sound Off!

Get NSN in your Inbox

Enter your email address to get notifications of new posts by email.

Follow NSN on Twitter

Most Viewed

Has Franklin lost the team? Coach weighs in on that question
Sophomore safety Gordon enters transfer portal: A look at what it means for PSU
Recruiting notebook: What could have been: Revisiting PSU's heralded 2018 class
5 Things many people are wrong about with James Franklin
5 Things James Franklin said today that you should know about. And why did he punt trailing late in game?
That's a clown question, Bro! Fans weigh in on what they would like to ask James Franklin
Blame game: 5 Things you cannot blame on James Franklin after PSU's 0-5 start
PSU basketball opener canceled because of COVID
For better or worse, James Franklin and Penn State are stuck with one another
Watch: James Franklin press conference on state of program after 0-5 start

More from Nittany Sports Now

PSU Basketball

0 It became abundantly clear on media day last week that some current members of the Penn State basketball team were not happy about...

PSU Basketball

0 Penn State star Lamar Stevens was not picked in the NBA draft Wednesday night. It wasn’t a huge surprise, given the big questions...

PSU Basketball

0 Penn State is fortunate to have Jim Ferry right now, during a crucial period in program history and a time when leadership and...

PSU Basketball

1 Lamar Stevens can do a lot of things well, which is why he became one of the best Penn State players of all...

Send this to a friend