Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Penn State Wrestling

Penn State Wrestling Legend Carter Starocci Accused of Misconduct

For Carter Starocci, winning the Hodge isn’t the main focus.
Photo by Penn State Wrestling: Carter Starocci

Penn State wrestling is legend Carter Starocci has been accused of misconduct.

A user by the name of Nittany Lion posted The Wrestling Room’s Facebook forum that Starocci was being investigated for “stealing from other PSU teammates.”

Pat Mineo of the Wrestling Room later confirms the post.

“Which sounds really odd if true, because he’s the highest paid wrestling athlete,” Mineo wrote. “Why would he need to steal?”

Syd Bartlett, the wife of Starocci’s former teammate Beau Bartlett, responded to Mineo’s post.

“He (Starocci) was being investigated for theft,” Bartlett wrote. “Aside from that investigation, he violated several of his teammates that are absolutely not appropriate in any way and to my knowledge faced no repressions for that behavior. I do not care how talented an individual is, how beneficial they may be for a team’s optics or results. If they are causing discomfort of ANY DEGREE in the locker room or outside of it, IN MY OPINION, action should be taken. End of story.”

Beau Bartlett wrote a long, cryptic post to Happy Valley Insider’s message board.

Part of it read “Any one person does not make an entire program.”

Add Nittany Sports Now as a preferred source in Google! Click here to add us.

Beau Bartlett Opens Up in Long, Cryptic Post

Another excerpt said

“She has had to listen to the things I’ve gone through while here, she’s had to listen to the even worse things her friends and other women have personally gone through over the years due to this same individual, she’s had to listen to the stories of my teammates and what they’ve experienced at the hands of this person, and she’s remained quiet through all of it despite being the most outspoken person I know, because there is a certain sense of intimidation that looms throughout the room and outside of it, and so many people, myself included, will more than likely never feel safe coming forward with their full stories.”

It’s important to note that Beau Bartlett didn’t mention Starocci by name, and it remains to be seen what more Bartlett will reveal.

Starocci ended his college wrestling career at Penn State this March with his fifth national championship, the first person in DI history to accomplish that feat.

This is a developing story and Nittany Sports Now will have updates when more information becomes available.

Get NSN in your Inbox

Enter your email address to get notifications of new posts by email.

More from Nittany Sports Now

Penn State Wrestling Recruiting

2s Penn State wrestling signee Elijah Brown might have gotten of a workout after the match than he did during. In this past weekend’s...

Penn State Wrestling Recruiting

1 The night didn’t go the way Penn State wrestling signee Jayden James had planned. Competing at 160 pounds, James, who is the No....

Penn State Wrestling

1 By winning the Dan Hodge Trophy, Penn State wrestling star Mitchell Mesenbrink did than add another accolade to Penn State wrestling’s overflowing trophy...

Penn State Hockey

0s Penn State’s 2025-26 season ended in the opposite fashion of the year before. Last season, the Nittany Lions were one of the hottest...